|

Potbelly Menu: A Wreck, Toasted Subs and Shakes

Potbelly Menu

Potbelly started in a Chicago antique shop in 1977. Peter Hastings toasted sandwiches on a potbelly stove for browsing customers, and the sandwiches soon outshone the antiques. The shop kept the stove’s name, and the toasting step never left.

Every sub still passes through a 500-degree oven, so the bread crisps and the cheese melts properly. Sizes matter here: Skinny, Original and BIG change the same sandwich by hundreds of calories. Soups, salads, shakes and cookies round out the board below.

Menu: pick a category

10 Best Value Items

Ten picks running the whole board, subs and soups first, shakes last, with A Wreck leading the way.

#ItemWhy Try ItPrice
1A WreckThe signature four-meat stack, the sandwich the shop is judged on.$9.59
2ItalianThe classic deli quartet, toasted until the edges crisp.$9.59
3Turkey Breast & SwissThe leanest classic sub, and the anchor of the $7.99 combo.$9.19
4Grilled Chicken & CheddarThe best protein-per-calorie sandwich on the board.$9.19
5Broccoli Cheddar SoupThe most-ordered soup, velvety cheddar loaded with broccoli.$4.89
6Powerhouse SaladGrilled chicken and avocado over greens, no gluten or milk flag.$9.89
7Oatmeal Chocolate Chip CookieThe famous in-shop cookie, chewy oatmeal loaded with chips.$2.29
8Whole PickleA whole dill pickle, the cheapest item on the menu.$1.29
9Chicken Bacon Ranch WrapThe highest-protein item on the whole menu at 67g.$12.59
10Skinny Turkey ComboA Skinny sub with chips, a genuine sub-$8 lunch.$7.99

Start with these ten, then work through the full menu below.

Signature Sandwiches

Twenty toasted subs, all run through the 500-degree oven, with the turkey breast and Mediterranean tied at 520.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
A Wreck650Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.59-$10.49Solo
Italian770Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.59-$10.49Solo
Turkey Breast & Swiss520Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Smoked Ham & Swiss590Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Roast Beef & Provolone610Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Grilled Chicken & Cheddar570Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Grilled Chicken Club770Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.99-$10.99Solo
Avo Turkey640Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.99-$10.99Solo
BLTA840Wheat, Soy$9.49-$10.49Solo
Mediterranean670Wheat, Milk, Soy, Sesame$9.99-$10.99Solo
Mediterranean No Chicken520Wheat, Milk, Soy, Sesame$9.99-$10.99Solo
Veggie Melt750Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Grilled Cheese640Wheat, Milk, Soy$8.39-$9.29Budget
Tuna Salad & Swiss690Wheat, Milk, Egg, Fish, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Chicken Salad & Provolone760Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.19-$9.99Solo
Cubano800Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.59-$10.49Solo
Mama's Meatball920Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.59-$10.49Solo
Pizza Melt820Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.59-$10.49Solo
Prime Rib Steak880Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$10.99-$11.99Solo
Sweet Heat Pork BBQ950Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.89-$10.89Solo

Hot peppers are free on any sandwich, and regulars ask for them by name.

Underground Menu

Nine app-unlocked builds for regulars who know the code, with the chicken cordon bleu as the lightest at 710.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Smokestack Pork & Mac1010Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.89-$10.89Solo
Street Corn Chicken750Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.89-$10.89Solo
Fiery Island Chicken720Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.89-$10.89Solo
Chicken Cordon Bleu710Wheat, Milk, Soy$9.89-$10.89Solo
Wrecking Ball850Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.99-$10.99Solo
Barnyard1010Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.99-$10.99Sharing
Sicilian980Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.99-$10.99Solo
Fireball1020Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$9.99-$10.99Solo
Lucky 71020Wheat, Milk, Soy$10.49-$11.49Sharing

All nine are toasted subs, priced between $9.89 and $11.49.

Wraps

Two wrap-only builds in a high-fibre flaxseed wrap, with the southwest avo chicken wrap as the lightest at 710.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap820Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy, Sesame$12.59-$13.49Solo
Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap710Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy, Sesame$12.59-$13.49Solo

Keep wraps to three or fewer added toppings, or they will not close properly.

Salads

Five salads, full or half, dressing on the side, with the A Wreck salad as the lightest at 370.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Powerhouse Salad560Egg, Sesame$9.89-$10.89Healthy
Farmhouse Salad790Milk, Egg$9.89-$10.89Solo
A Wreck Salad370Milk, Egg$9.89-$10.89Healthy
Chicken Salad Salad870Milk, Egg$9.89-$10.89Solo
Apple Walnut Salad1070Milk, Tree Nut$9.89-$10.89Solo

Dressing runs 240 to 390 calories on a full salad, so ask for it on the side.

Soups & Macs

Nine soups and macs, bowls run about half again, with the garden vegetable soup as the lightest at 70.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Broccoli Cheddar Soup230Wheat, Milk, Soy$4.89-$5.49Solo
Mac & Cheese300Wheat, Milk, Egg$4.89-$5.49Solo
Chili250Wheat, Milk$4.89-$5.49Solo
Chili Mac300Wheat, Milk, Egg$4.89-$5.49Solo
Chicken Pot Pie Soup280Wheat, Milk, Soy$4.89-$5.49Solo
Loaded Baked Potato Soup210Wheat, Milk, Soy$4.89-$5.49Solo
Garden Vegetable Soup70Soy$4.89-$5.49Healthy
Pork BBQ Mac600Wheat, Milk, Egg$5.49-$5.99Solo
Southwest Corn Chowder220Wheat, Milk, Soy$4.89-$5.49Solo

Southwest Corn Chowder runs at select shops only, so check the board before planning around it.

Chips & Sides

Ten chips and sides led by Zapp's kettle bags, with the whole pickle as the lightest at 25.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Zapp's Regular Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's VooDoo Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's VooDoo Heat Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips220Milk$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's Mesquite BBQ Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's Hotter 'N Hot Jalapeno Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Zapp's Hot Pepper Chips220None$1.99-$2.29Solo
Baked Lay's140Soy$1.99-$2.29Solo
Utz Cheese Curls230Milk$1.99-$2.29Solo
Potbelly Whole Pickle25None$1.29-$1.49Budget

Every Zapp's bag runs 220 calories; only the sodium changes, from 130mg to 380mg.

Cookies & Shakes

Fifteen cookies and shakes baked and dipped in shop, with the oatmeal chip and brownie cookies tied at 420.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie420Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$2.29-$2.49Solo
Sugar Cookie520Wheat, Milk, Egg, Sesame$2.29-$2.49Solo
Chocolate Brownie Cookie420Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$2.29-$2.49Solo
Dream Bar430Wheat, Milk, Soy$2.49-$2.69Solo
S'more Cookie430Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$2.29-$2.49Solo
Lemon Cheesecake Cookie430Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$2.29-$2.49Solo
Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich1080Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$5.49-$5.99Sharing
Brownie Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich1080Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$5.49-$5.99Sharing
Sugar Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich1240Wheat, Milk, Egg$5.49-$5.99Sharing
Vanilla Shake700Wheat, Milk, Soy$5.19-$5.69Solo
Chocolate Shake770Wheat, Milk, Soy$5.19-$5.69Solo
Strawberry Shake710Wheat, Milk, Soy$5.19-$5.69Solo
OREO Shake770Wheat, Milk, Soy$5.49-$5.99Solo
Cold Brew Shake680Wheat, Milk, Soy$5.49-$5.99Solo
Banana Pudding Shake710Milk$5.49-$5.99Solo

Cookies sell out at peak lunch, so order yours before the sub hits the toaster.

Drinks

Ten fountain and bottled drinks where size swings the total, with the diet coke and bottled water at zero.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Coca-Cola270-400None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Diet Coke0None$2.59-$2.89Healthy
Sprite240-360None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Dr Pepper240-360None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Fanta Orange260-400None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Minute Maid Lemonade230-340None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Sweetened Iced Tea280-420None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Unsweetened Iced Tea0-5None$2.59-$2.89Healthy
Fuze Raspberry Tea140-200None$2.59-$2.89Solo
Bottled Water0None$2.49-$2.79Solo

Choosing 20 oz over 30 oz saves 110 to 140 calories on a regular soda or lemonade.

Kids Meals

Four kids combos, each with applesauce and a cookie, with the turkey and swiss combo as the lightest at 460.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Kid's Turkey & Swiss Combo460Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$5.99Kids
Kid's Ham & Swiss Combo500Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$5.99Kids
Kid's Mac & Cheese Combo530Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy$5.99Kids
Kid's PB&J Combo740Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy, Peanut$5.99Kids

Kids milk and chocolate milk are available as drink swaps.

Combos & Deals

Six combos and deals with chips included, drinks extra, with the pick your pair running 320 to 1,140.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Skinny Turkey Combo490-580Wheat, Milk, Soy$7.99Solo
Skinny Chicken Combo520-610Wheat, Milk, Soy$7.99Solo
Skinny Ham Combo530-620Wheat, Milk, Soy$7.99Solo
Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich and Soup420-1090Varies$10.29Solo
Pick Your Pair Half Salad and Soup320-1140Varies$10.69Solo
Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich and Half Salad600-1030Varies$11.59Solo

The Skinny combos include chips but not a drink, so budget $2.59 more.

Portion Guide

An Original sub fills most appetites, and a Skinny cuts about a third of the calories. A BIG adds substantially more of everything, so save it for a hungry day. A cup of soup works as a side, while a bowl works as a light meal. A shake lands between 680 and 770 calories, so it is dessert on its own.

Budget Picks

Start cheap with a cup of Garden Vegetable Soup at $4.89. Add a whole pickle at $1.29 and Baked Lay's at $1.99, and the whole meal comes to $8.17. A Skinny Turkey Combo at $7.99 plus a fountain drink at $2.59 totals $10.58, which covers lunch under eleven dollars. For a family of four, two A Wreck subs at $9.59 each plus two bags of Zapp's at $1.99 each totals $23.16, about $5.79 per person.

Allergy Guide

Wheat and milk run through most of this menu, since nearly every sandwich carries bread and cheese. Soy follows close behind, because both breads carry a soy flag. Salads skip the bread, so they are where wheat and soy largely disappear. The wrap adds sesame, and the Apple Walnut Salad is the only tree nut item. Tuna is the only fish item, and shellfish appears nowhere. Shared toasters and prep areas mean cross-contact is possible, so flag a severe allergy at the counter before the sub hits the toaster.

You Might Also Like

If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.

FAQs

What do Skinny, Original and BIG mean at Potbelly?

Skinny uses thinner-cut bread and a lighter meat portion, for about a dollar less and roughly 30 to 40 percent fewer calories. Original is the standard build every price here refers to. BIG adds substantially more of everything. A Wreck runs 440 as a Skinny, 650 as an Original, and 930 as a BIG.

Does the $7.99 Potbelly combo include a drink?

No. The Skinny combos bundle a Skinny sandwich with a bag of chips only. A fountain drink runs about $2.59 extra. Buying the sandwich and chips separately runs roughly $11.18, so the combo saves about $3.19.

Can any Potbelly sandwich be made as a wrap?

Yes. Every Originals sandwich can be built in the Damascus flaxseed wrap, which runs 220 calories with 15g of fibre on its own. The wrap carries a sesame flag on the official chart, so every wrap build inherits it. The Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap at 710 calories is the lightest wrap-only build.

Is anything at Potbelly certified gluten free?

No. Potbelly certifies no item as gluten free and offers no gluten-free bread. The Powerhouse Salad carries no gluten flag on the official chart, and salads skip the bread entirely. Shared preparation surfaces mean cross-contact is still possible.

What is the Potbelly Underground Menu?

The Underground Menu is a set of app-unlocked builds, including the Wrecking Ball, Barnyard, Sicilian, Fireball and Lucky 7. They are not printed on the shop board. Describing one at the counter works too, since the crew knows the builds.

What is Pick Your Pair?

Pick Your Pair pairs two half-portions: a Skinny sandwich plus soup for $10.29, a half salad plus soup for $10.69, or a Skinny sandwich plus a half salad for $11.59. The lightest build, a half A Wreck Salad with a cup of Garden Vegetable soup, lands near 320 calories.

Bottom Line

Order A Wreck with hots first. The Italian and the Mediterranean cover the deli and balanced ends of the board. End with a cookie from the in-shop case, baked through the day.

Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.

Similar Posts