Picklemans Menu: Toasted Clubs, Thin Pizzas

A toasted roll does most of the talking at Pickleman’s. The crunch lands first. Then the fillings take over, sliced deli meat, melted cheese, and a sauce that actually tastes like something.
That crunch is the thread through the whole menu. Sandwiches lead it. Thin pizzas, cheesy bowls, chopped salads, and warm soups follow. Ten favorites open the list below. After them, each section lists its own prices, calories and allergens, so you can compare before you order.
10 Best Value Items
Ten orders regulars reach for first, picked for flavor, filling size, and fair cost, a good place to start.
| # | Item | Why Try It | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | #11 Italian Club | Four deli meats, provolone, and Italian seasoning on a toasted roll. | $10.38 |
| 2 | #1 Turkey | Honey mesquite turkey with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. | $9.28 |
| 3 | #9 Italian Beef | Shaved beef dipped in au jus, with spicy giardiniera and extra jus. | $11.48 |
| 4 | #17 Chipotle Chicken | Grilled chicken with chipotle ranch, the smoky crowd favorite. | $10.16 |
| 5 | #5 Turkey Bacon Club | Turkey, smoked bacon, and provolone, a classic club done right. | $10.05 |
| 6 | Pepperoni Pizza | Crispy thin crust, marinara, and plenty of pepperoni to share. | $13.68 |
| 7 | Mac and Cheese | Creamy white cheddar mac, the cheapest warm bowl on the menu. | $5.98 |
| 8 | Tomato Basil Bisque | Caramelized onion and red pepper flake warmth, with artisan bread. | $5.98 |
| 9 | Cafe Chop Salad | Turkey, ham, cheddar, and chipotle ranch, chopped fresh to order. | $8.18 |
| 10 | Garlic Cheese Bread | Mozzarella, whipped garlic butter, and marinara for dipping. | $5.40 |
These ten cover the strongest flavors at Pickleman's without the highest prices. Try one, then work through the categories below.
Toasted Sandwiches
Seventeen toasted rolls led by the Italian Club and the Italian Beef, with the italian beef lightest at 480.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 Turkey | 640 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $9.28-$9.88 | Solo |
| #2 Ham | 620 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $8.73-$9.33 | Solo |
| #3 Veggie | 640 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $7.63-$8.23 | Solo |
| #4 Chicken Salad | 680 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg, Tree Nut | $9.61-$10.21 | Solo |
| #5 Turkey Bacon Club | 800 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.05-$10.65 | Solo |
| #6 Asiago Chicken | 780 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.16-$10.76 | Solo |
| #7 Hodge Podge | 950 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $12.58-$13.18 | Sharing |
| #8 Cafe Club | 720 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.05-$10.65 | Solo |
| #9 Italian Beef | 480 | Wheat | $11.48-$12.08 | Solo |
| #10 Meatball Sub (Limited Time Only) | 850 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $12.60-$13.20 | Solo |
| #11 Italian Club | 910 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.38-$10.98 | Solo |
| #12 Smokehouse Stack | 880 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $11.48-$12.08 | Solo |
| #13 B.L.T.C. | 790 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $9.28-$9.88 | Solo |
| #14 BBQ Pulled Pork | 820 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.05-$10.65 | Solo |
| #15 Buffalo Chicken | 730 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $10.16-$10.76 | Solo |
| #16 Grilled Cheese | 640 | Dairy, Wheat | $6.53-$7.13 | Budget |
| #17 Chipotle Chicken | 750 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg, Soy | $10.16-$10.76 | Solo |
Sandwiches are built on a toasted white or wheat club roll with meats and cheeses sliced daily. Any sandwich can become a romaine lettuce wrap, and half sandwiches are offered through the Pick 2 option.
Pizzas
Nine thin crust pizzas led by Pepperoni and the loaded Hog, with the veggie as the lightest at 1,080.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chipotle Beef | 1420 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $21.90-$22.50 | Sharing |
| Cheese | 1150 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $12.58-$13.18 | Sharing |
| Pepperoni | 1310 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $13.68-$14.28 | Sharing |
| Italian Sausage | 1290 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $14.78-$15.38 | Sharing |
| Veggie | 1080 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $19.70-$20.30 | Sharing |
| BBQ Chicken | 1240 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $20.08-$20.68 | Sharing |
| Asiago Chicken | 1330 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $19.18-$19.78 | Sharing |
| Buffalo Chicken | 1280 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $18.08-$18.68 | Sharing |
| The Hog | 1580 | Dairy, Wheat, Soy | $19.40-$20.00 | Sharing |
Pizzas are 12 inch thin crust pies with a whole milk cheese blend and housemade marinara. One pizza feeds two light eaters, or one very hungry fan.
Mac and Cheese Bowls
Six white cheddar bowls led by the plain bowl and Chicken Bacon Ranch, with the plain bowl lightest at 360.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mac and Cheese | 360 | Dairy, Wheat | $5.98-$6.58 | Budget |
| BBQ Pulled Pork | 620 | Dairy, Wheat | $9.28-$9.88 | Solo |
| Spicy Pork | 640 | Dairy, Wheat | $9.30-$9.90 | Solo |
| Buffalo Chicken | 610 | Dairy, Wheat | $9.28-$9.88 | Solo |
| Chipotle Chicken | 630 | Dairy, Wheat | $9.30-$9.90 | Solo |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | 660 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $9.28-$9.88 | Solo |
Bowls start with creamy white cheddar mac and cheese, then take a loaded topping. The plain bowl is the lightest and cheapest way into this section.
Soups
Three warming bowls led by Tomato Basil Bisque and Broccoli Cheese, with the broccoli cheese as the lightest at 230.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loaded Baked Potato (Limited Time Only) | 380 (8 oz), 540 (12 oz) | Dairy, Wheat | $6.00-$8.30 | Solo |
| Broccoli Cheese | 230 (8 oz), 350 (12 oz) | Dairy, Wheat | $5.98-$8.23 | Solo |
| Tomato Basil Bisque | 280 (8 oz), 420 (12 oz) | Dairy, Wheat | $5.98-$8.23 | Solo |
Soups come in 8 oz and 12 oz bowls, each with a chunk of artisan bread. The 12 oz bowl pairs well with a half sandwich for a full lunch.
Salads
Eight chopped salads led by Cafe Chop and the Avo-Cobb, with the garden chop salad as the lightest at 230.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken Caesar Salad | 340 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $7.90-$9.50 | Solo |
| Asiago Caesar Salad | 260 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $5.98-$7.45 | Solo |
| Garden Chop Salad | 230 | Dairy, Wheat | $6.50-$7.70 | Healthy |
| Walnut Cran Salad | 420 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg, Tree Nut | $7.40-$8.80 | Solo |
| Italian Chop | 520 | Dairy, Wheat | $8.73-$9.33 | Solo |
| Cafe Chop Salad | 480 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $8.18-$9.33 | Solo |
| Avo-Cobb Salad | 570 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $8.18-$9.18 | Solo |
| Buffalo Chicken | 540 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $7.85-$9.18 | Solo |
Salads are chopped fresh with romaine or spinach, and dressings arrive on the side. That keeps the greens crisp and lets you control how much dressing goes on.
Sides
Six small plates led by Garlic Cheese Bread and the Chicken Salad, with the pickles as the lightest at 15.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kettle-Cooked Chips | 150 | None | $2.40-$3.00 | Quick Bite |
| Pickles | 15 | None | $1.70-$2.30 | Quick Bite |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | 380 | Dairy, Wheat, Egg | $2.90-$3.50 | Quick Bite |
| Garlic Cheese Bread | 520 | Dairy, Wheat | $5.40-$6.00 | Sharing |
| Chicken Salad | 340 | Dairy, Egg, Tree Nut | $5.90-$6.50 | Solo |
| Giardiniera Peppers | 35 | None | $6.90-$7.50 | Sharing |
Sides are built to pair with a sandwich or soup. The garlic bread and the pickle jar both travel well, so they work for takeout too.
Beverages
Six drink picks led by Lemonade and Strawberry Lemonade, with the unsweet tea at zero, the fountain sodas at 200.
| Item | Calories | Allergens | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fountain Sodas | 140-200 | None | $2.70-$3.30 | Solo |
| Unsweet Tea | 0 | None | $2.70-$3.30 | Healthy |
| Sweet Tea | 90 | None | $2.70-$3.30 | Solo |
| Lemonade | 120 | None | $3.40-$4.00 | Solo |
| Strawberry Lemonade | 140 | None | $3.70-$4.30 | Solo |
| Kids Drinks | 80-110 | Dairy (milk only) | $2.40-$3.00 | Kids |
Drinks cover Coke fountain products, organic black tea, and 3-ingredient lemonade. Kids drinks are apple juice or organic white or chocolate milk.
Portion Guide
One full sandwich fills one adult at lunch. A half sandwich works when soup or a salad joins it.
One 12 inch pizza splits between two people without a struggle. Add a salad and it stretches to three light eaters.
One mac bowl is a solo meal. One soup in 12 oz eats like a light meal on its own.
Budget Picks
Start small with a Grilled Cheese at $6.53 and a Pickle at $1.70. That snack-sized pair comes to $8.23.
For one full lunch, take a #1 Turkey at $9.28 with Kettle-Cooked Chips at $2.40. That plate comes to $11.68.
Feeding four? Order a Pepperoni Pizza at $13.68 and a Cheese Pizza at $12.58, then four Fountain Sodas at $2.70 each. That round comes to $37.06.
Allergy Guide
Wheat runs through nearly every roll, pizza crust, and mac bowl here. Dairy follows close behind, in cheese, butter, and creamy dressings.
The safest plain picks are pickles, unsweet tea, and lemonade. Lettuce wraps drop the roll, but the fillings still carry their own allergens.
Kitchens here share grills, boards, and fryers across the menu. Guests with a severe allergy should flag it when ordering and confirm prep steps.
You Might Also Like
If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.
Subway Menu
Jason's Deli Menu
Panera Menu
Arby's Menu
McDonald's Menu
Chick-fil-A Menu
Chipotle Menu
Cheesecake Factory MenuFAQs
What is the most popular sandwich at Pickleman's?
The #11 Italian Club is the name regulars mention most, and the official menu page features it first among the clubs. It stacks four deli meats with provolone and Italian seasoning. The #1 Turkey is the lighter classic behind it.
Does Pickleman's have a gluten-free menu?
No gluten-free crust or roll is listed on the current official menu. Lettuce wraps swap the roll for romaine on any sandwich. Ask the store about prep, since shared surfaces still carry wheat.
Can I order a half sandwich at Pickleman's?
Yes, the Pick 2 option covers any half sandwich. Pair it with a soup or a salad for a full lunch. A half sandwich also works well with the 12 oz soup size.
Does Pickleman's deliver?
Yes, through third-party delivery platforms at participating stores. Delivery prices run higher than in-store prices. Ordering direct for pickup keeps the bill closest to the bands in this guide.
What dressings does Pickleman's offer on salads?
Dressings are served on the side and vary by salad, from chipotle ranch to balsamic vinaigrette and twisted citrus. Each salad lists its own dressing on the official menu. Ask for dressing on the side if yours ever arrives mixed.
Does Pickleman's have vegetarian options?
Yes, the #3 Veggie sandwich and the Garden Chop Salad are the clearest meat-free picks. The plain Mac and Cheese and the Cheese Pizza work too. The #4 Chicken Salad is not vegetarian, since it contains chicken plus walnuts.
Bottom Line
Start with the #11 Italian Club if you want the full Pickleman's experience. Pick the #1 Turkey or a chopped salad when you want something lighter. Add a soup or garlic bread, and the meal feels complete.
Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.






