|

Peter Luger Menu: Steak for Two & Holy Cow

peter luger menu

You do not pick a cut at Peter Luger. You pick a headcount, and a dry-aged porterhouse arrives sliced on a hot platter.

That single choice shapes the whole bill, since sides, salads and desserts are ordered apart. The ten picks below give first-timers a clear starting order, then the full menu follows section by section.

10 Best Value Items

Ten items Peter Luger fans order again and again, the tastiest, most budget-friendly picks worth every penny.

#ItemWhy Try ItPrice
1Steak for TwoThe signature dry-aged porterhouse, sliced for the table.$155.90
2Single SteakThe same porterhouse cut, sized for one diner.$77.95
3Luger BurgerA half-pound Prime burger, lunch only and far below steak prices.$22.95
4Creamed Spinach (for 2)The side nearly every table orders with steak.$18.95
5Luger's Special German Fried Potatoes (for 2)Crisp-edged potatoes that soak up the steak juices.$18.95
6Luger's Sizzling BaconOne extra-thick slice per person is plenty.$8.95
7Caesar SaladRomaine with pecorino and homemade croutons, a sharp starter.$18.95
8Iceberg Wedge SaladCold crunch with tomato, bacon and blue cheese.$23.95
9Lamb ChopsTwo double-thick loin chops for guests who skip beef.$72.95
10Luger's Special Holy Cow Hot Fudge SundaeThe giant sundae finish, served with homemade Schlag.$18.95

These are the most-ordered items at Peter Luger, chosen for value, taste, and popularity. Try these first, then explore the full menu below.

USDA Prime Beef

Five dry-aged porterhouse orders per person led by Steak for Two, with the single steak as the lightest at 950.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Steak for Two1200 per personMilk$147.90-$155.90Sharing
Steak for Three1150 per personMilk$244.85-$254.85Sharing
Steak for Four1100 per personMilk$305.80-$320.80Family
Single Steak950 per personMilk$73.95-$77.95Solo
Rib Steak for One or Two1050 per personMilk$92.95-$199.90Sharing

Beef here is family selected and dry-aged in the house drying box. Each porterhouse order arrives sliced on a hot platter for the table.

Appetizers & Salads

Eight starters and salads a serving led by thick-cut bacon and shrimp cocktail, with the sliced tomatoes lightest at 110.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Sliced Tomatoes & Onions (for 2)110 per servingFish, Soy$14.95-$17.95Sharing
Luger's Sizzling Bacon, Extra Thick by the Slice280 per sliceNone$8.95Sharing
Caesar Salad320 per servingMilk, Wheat, Egg, Fish$18.95Solo
Iceberg Wedge Salad480 per servingMilk$23.95Solo
House Salad210 per servingNone$17.95Healthy
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)180 per servingShellfish$22.95Sharing
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, Extra Large Portion (6)260 per servingShellfish$32.95Sharing
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake (1)380 per servingShellfish, Wheat, Egg$35.95Solo

Starters here run simple and cold or crisp, which suits a heavy steak to follow. Salads can take chopped shrimp or chopped bacon as an add-on.

Entrees

Six non-steak mains a serving led by lamb chops and grilled salmon, with the filet of sole lightest at 380.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Lamb Chops, 2 Double Thick Loin Chops780 per servingNone$72.95Solo
Grilled Atlantic Salmon520 per servingFish$39.95Solo
Filet of Sole380 per servingFish, Milk$39.95Solo
Chicken Broiled, One Half620 per servingMilk$39.95Solo
Chopped Steak, USDA Prime, 1 lb. Smothered with Onions850 per servingMilk$54.95Solo
Lobster, Broiled Maine, Whole720 per servingShellfish, Milk$94.95Solo

Chicken, chopped steak and lobster appear on the Great Neck menu, while lamb, salmon and sole appear at both New York rooms. Chopped steak is unavailable for dinner on Friday, Saturday and holidays at Great Neck.

Vegetables & Sides

Eight shared sides an order led by creamed spinach and German potatoes, with the grilled asparagus lightest at 90.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
French Fried Potatoes (for 2)640 per orderNone$18.95Sharing
Fresh Broccoli (for 2)120 per orderNone$16.95Healthy
Creamed Spinach (for 2)380 per orderMilk$18.95Sharing
Onion Rings (for 2)580 per orderWheat$17.95Sharing
Luger's Special German Fried Potatoes (for 2)620 per orderNone$18.95Sharing
Baked Oversized Potato with Sour Cream420 per servingMilk$9.95Solo
Roasted Mushrooms (for 2)210 per orderMilk$17.95Sharing
Grilled Asparagus90 per servingNone$16.95Healthy

Sides are ordered apart from steak and sized for sharing, except the baked potato. Baked potatoes depend on availability on the day.

Lunch

Two lunch-only mains a serving led by the half-pound Luger Burger, with the steak sandwich as the lightest at 760.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Luger Burger980 per servingWheat, Milk$21.95-$22.95Solo
Steak Sandwich760 per servingWheat, Milk$37.95Solo

The Luger Burger runs daily until 3:45 PM in Brooklyn and until 4:00 PM in Great Neck. Cheese, bacon and French fries are optional adds on the burger, not included by default.

Desserts

Ten sweet finishes a serving all served with homemade Schlag, with the fresh fruit as the lightest at 180.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Apple Strudel520 per servingWheat, Milk, Egg$14.95Sharing
Cheese Cake540 per servingWheat, Milk, Egg$14.95Sharing
Chocolate Mousse480 per servingMilk, Egg$14.95Solo
Fruit Tarts420 per servingWheat, Milk, Egg$14.95Solo
Key Lime Pie460 per servingWheat, Milk, Egg$14.95Sharing
Pecan Pie580 per servingWheat, Milk, Egg, Tree Nuts$14.95Sharing
Ice Cream320 per servingMilk$14.95Solo
Sorbet240 per servingNone$14.95Healthy
Fresh Fruit in Season180 per servingNone$14.95Healthy
Luger's Special Holy Cow Hot Fudge Sundae890 per servingMilk$18.95Sharing

Schlag is the house whipped cream served with desserts. The Holy Cow sundae is the largest dessert on the menu, so it suits sharing after steak.

Portion Guide

Steak for Two feeds two hungry diners. Steak for Three feeds three, and Steak for Four feeds four, though moderate eaters often order one size down.

One side for two covers two people when the table shares. One baked potato covers one person.

One dessert covers one person, except the Holy Cow sundae, which two people can share. One burger or one steak sandwich is a solo lunch.

Budget Picks

The cheapest solo lunch pairs the Luger Burger at $22.95 with a Baked Oversized Potato at $9.95, for $32.90 in total.

A dinner for two pairs Steak for Two at $155.90 with Creamed Spinach at $18.95 and German Fried Potatoes at $18.95, for $193.80 before tax and tip.

A group dinner pairs Steak for Four at $320.80 with Creamed Spinach at $18.95, German Fried Potatoes at $18.95 and French Fried Potatoes at $18.95, for $377.65 in total, or $94.41 per person for four before tax and tip.

Allergy Guide

Wheat shows up in the burger bun, croutons, onion rings and dessert pastry. Milk shows up in butter finishes, creamed spinach, sour cream and most desserts.

Shellfish covers shrimp, crab and lobster only. Fish covers salmon, sole and the anchovy in Luger's Own Sauce.

Plain steak without sauce, plain broccoli and fresh fruit are the simplest picks. Kitchens here share grills and prep space, so guests with a severe allergy should ring the store first and confirm prep steps.

You Might Also Like

If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.

FAQs

Does Peter Luger accept credit cards for in-person dining?

No, for in-person dining at Brooklyn and Great Neck, accepted payment is cash, US debit cards, US checks with valid photo ID, and Peter Luger house accounts. Credit cards are accepted for online ordering only.

How far ahead should you book a table at Peter Luger?

Book weeks ahead for Brooklyn, which fills fastest. Great Neck is usually easier to get into. Cancel ahead if plans change, since tables are held against the booking.

Is the Luger Burger available at dinner?

No. The burger is a lunch line, served daily until 3:45 PM in Brooklyn and until 4:00 PM in Great Neck. After that cutoff, the room moves to the full steak menu.

What does Steak for Two actually mean?

It means one dry-aged porterhouse, sliced and served on a hot platter for two people. It is not two separate steaks. Moderate eaters often order one size down from their party size.

Can you buy raw Peter Luger steak to take home?

Yes, through the butcher shop line. Raw porterhouse and raw sirloin are sold to take away, along with a bottle of Peter Luger Sauce at $5.50.

Does Peter Luger have vegetarian options?

The choice is narrow. Salads, vegetable sides, and desserts carry the meat-free side of the menu. There is no meat-free main dish, so vegetarians build a meal from starters, sides, and dessert.

Bottom Line

Order the porterhouse for one fewer person than your party size, add creamed spinach and German potatoes, and finish with the Holy Cow sundae. Lunch visitors should aim for the burger window before it ends. Guests who want a lighter plate can build a meal from salads and vegetable sides instead.

Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.

Similar Posts