|

Godfathers Pizza Menu: Thick Crust and Buffet

godfathers pizza menu
Menu: pick a category

Godfather's has sold thick-crust pizza since 1973, the year the movie hit theaters. The name is a nod to the film. The pizza is a pie in the old sense: thick crust, heavy toppings, and mountains of mozzarella holding it all together.

The menu still runs on that same idea. Taco Pie and Classic Combo sit next to a buffet, Broaster chicken, calzones, and wings. Sizes run Mini to Jumbo, and every pie comes on your choice of four crusts. Prices below are typical US bands, since each store sets its own.

10 Best Value Items

Ten picks that cover the cheapest pizzas, the lightest slices, and the best deals.

#ItemWhy Try ItPrice
1Cheese PizzaTied as the cheapest pizza at $15.99, 230 calories a Large slice.$15.99
2Pepperoni PizzaThe classic single-topping pick, 270 calories a Large slice.$18.99
3Classic ComboThe signature pie, 300 calories a Large slice.$25.99
4Taco PieThe famous one, 330 calories a Large slice.$25.99
5Veggie PieThe lightest specialty at 240 calories a Large slice.$25.99
6Thin Crust CheeseThe lightest slice on the menu at 190 calories a Large slice.$15.99
7Lunch BuffetAll-you-can-eat lunch for $11.99, pizza, chicken, and salad bar.$11.99
8Big Chocolate Chip CookieThe cheapest dessert at $5.99, 190 calories a sixth.$5.99
9Boneless Naked WingsThe lightest wings at 430 calories a half order.$8.99
10Pepperoni CalzoneA whole meal in one pocket, 620 calories.$9.99

Pick a favorite above, then see the whole Godfather's menu below.

Specialty Pizzas

Fourteen house pies on Golden Crust, from 240 to 360 calories a Large slice.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Classic Combo300Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Taco Pie330Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
All-Meat Combo320Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Humble Pie320Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Hot Stuff310Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Bacon Cheeseburger300Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Veggie Pie240Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Hawaiian270Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Super Combo340Milk, Soy, Wheat$28.99-$32.99Sharing
Super Taco Pie360Milk, Soy, Wheat$28.99-$32.99Sharing
Super Hawaiian270Milk, Soy, Wheat$28.99-$32.99Sharing
The Don340Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Baja Taco300Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Sicilian Veggie260Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo

Super Taco Pie is the heaviest here at 360 calories a Large slice. Veggie Pie is the lightest at 240. Taco Pie is the signature build of the house.

Classic Pizzas

Twelve cheese and one-topping builds, from 230 to 310 calories a Large slice.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Cheese230Milk, Soy, Wheat$15.99-$18.99Solo
Pepperoni270Milk, Soy, Wheat$18.99-$22.99Solo
Beef270Milk, Soy, Wheat$18.99-$22.99Solo
Sausage270Milk, Soy, Wheat$18.99-$22.99Solo
Ham240Milk, Soy, Wheat$18.99-$22.99Solo
Italian Sausage300Milk, Soy, Wheat$19.99-$23.99Solo
Triple Meat310Milk, Soy, Wheat$21.99-$25.99Sharing
Sausage & Pepperoni290Milk, Soy, Wheat$19.99-$23.99Solo
Pepperoni & Hatch Chile270Milk, Soy, Wheat$19.99-$23.99Solo
Ham & Pineapple250Milk, Soy, Wheat$23.99-$27.99Solo
BLT280Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Reuben270Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo

Triple Meat tops this table at 310 calories a Large slice. Cheese is the lightest at 230.

Chicken Pizzas

Eight chicken builds, from 270 to 350 calories a Large slice.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
BBQ Chicken270Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Buffalo Chicken320Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$29.99-$33.99Solo
Chicken Alfredo270Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Chicken Bacon Ranch320Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$29.99-$33.99Solo
Chicken Royale350Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$29.99-$33.99Solo
Pesto Chicken & Spinach300Milk, Soy, Tree Nut, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Chicken Sausage Italiano280Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Chicken Taco Pie300Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo

Chicken Royale is the heaviest at 350 calories a Large slice. BBQ Chicken and Chicken Alfredo tie as the lightest at 270.

Thin Crust Pizzas

Eight favorites on light and crispy Thin Crust, from 190 to 320 calories a Large slice.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
All-Meat Combo280Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Classic Combo260Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Cheese190Milk, Soy, Wheat$15.99-$18.99Solo
Pepperoni230Milk, Soy, Wheat$18.99-$22.99Solo
Taco Pie280Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Sharing
Super Taco Pie320Milk, Soy, Wheat$28.99-$32.99Sharing
Veggie Pie200Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo
Hawaiian230Milk, Soy, Wheat$25.99-$29.99Solo

Super Taco Pie is the heaviest thin slice at 320 calories. Cheese is the lightest at 190.

Calzones & Pizza Rolls

Six calzones and three pizza rolls, from 550 to 700 calories each.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
All-Meat Combo Calzone690Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Bacon Cheeseburger Calzone670Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Classic Combo Calzone660Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Lottsa Mozza Calzone630Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Pepperoni Calzone620Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Sausage & Pepperoni Calzone630Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Solo
Pepperoni Pizza Roll610Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.99Quick Bite
Ham Pizza Roll550Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.99Quick Bite
Pepperoni & Jalapeno Pizza Roll700Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.99Quick Bite

The Pepperoni and Jalapeno roll is the heaviest at 700 calories. The Ham roll is the lightest at 550.

Wings

Boneless and bone-in wings by the half order, from 430 to 1,090 calories.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Boneless Naked Wings (1/2 order)430Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless BBQ Wings (1/2 order)600Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless Buffalo Wings (1/2 order)530Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless Garlic Parmesan Wings (1/2 order)930Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless Honey Mustard Wings (1/2 order)790Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless Sweet Chili Wings (1/2 order)640Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Boneless Teriyaki Wings (1/2 order)550Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Bone-In Naked Wings (1/2 order)590None$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Bone-In BBQ Wings (1/2 order)750Soy$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Bone-In Buffalo Wings (1/2 order)680Soy$8.99-$11.99Sharing
Bone-In Garlic Parmesan Wings (1/2 order)1090Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Sharing

Garlic Parmesan bone-in is the heaviest half order at 1,090 calories. Boneless Naked is the lightest at 430.

Broaster Chicken & Sides

Broaster chicken pieces and homestyle sides, from 60 to 460 calories a serving.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Broaster Chicken Breast460Soy, Wheat$4.99-$6.49Solo
Broaster Chicken Leg220Soy, Wheat$2.99-$3.99Solo
Broaster Chicken Thigh380Soy, Wheat$3.99-$4.99Solo
Broaster Chicken Wing220Soy, Wheat$2.49-$3.49Solo
Broaster Chicken Tender (Fresh)310Soy, Wheat$3.99-$5.49Solo
Broaster Chicken Tender (Pre-Breaded)410Soy, Wheat$3.99-$5.49Solo
Biscuit270Milk, Wheat$1.99-$2.99Extra
Baked Beans (4 oz)120None$2.99-$3.99Extra
Coleslaw (4 oz)140Egg, Milk$2.99-$3.99Extra
Corn (4 oz)110Milk$2.49-$3.49Extra
Green Beans (4 oz)60Soy$2.49-$3.49Extra
Potato Wedges (4 oz)170Soy$3.49-$4.49Extra

The Breast is the heaviest piece at 460 calories. Green Beans are the lightest side at 60.

Sides & Breads

Breads, wedges, and dipper cups, from 40 to 850 calories a serving.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Italian Monkey Bread (1 pan)460Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.99Sharing
Breadsticks (order of 5)850Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Sharing
Garlic Bread (1 piece)200Milk, Soy, Wheat$3.99-$5.49Extra
Garlic Bread with Cheese (1 piece)220Milk, Soy, Wheat$4.99-$6.49Extra
Potato Wedges (8 oz)350Soy$4.99-$6.99Sharing
Marinara Dipper Cup40None$0.75Extra
Ranch Dipper Cup230Egg, Milk, Soy$0.75Extra
BBQ Dipper Cup90Soy$0.75Extra
Garlic Parmesan Dipper Cup300Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$0.75Extra
Cheddar Cheese Dipper Cup90Milk$0.75Extra

A five-piece Breadsticks order is the heaviest at 850 calories. Marinara is the lightest at 40.

Breakfast Pizzas & Sandwiches

Morning pies and biscuit sandwiches, from 190 to 610 calories each.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Denver Omelet Pizza (Mini, 1/4)190Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$7.99-$9.99Solo
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Pizza (Mini, 1/4)200Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$7.99-$9.99Solo
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Pizza (Mini, 1/4)200Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$7.99-$9.99Solo
Ham, Egg & Cheese Pizza (Mini, 1/4)190Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$7.99-$9.99Solo
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (Biscuit)430Egg, Milk, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Solo
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (Biscuit)610Egg, Milk, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Solo
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (Croissant)400Egg, Milk, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Solo
Ham, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (Croissant)430Egg, Milk, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Solo

The Sausage, Egg and Cheese Biscuit is the heaviest at 610 calories. Denver Omelet and Ham, Egg and Cheese tie as the lightest pies at 190.

Salads & Sandwiches

Three grab-and-go salads and four oven-baked sandwiches, from 150 to 760 calories each.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Grab'n Go Chicken BLT Salad240Egg, Milk$6.99-$8.99Solo
Grab'n Go Italian Veggie Salad280Milk$6.99-$8.99Solo
Grab'n Go Italian Chef Salad150Egg, Milk$6.99-$8.99Solo
Ham & Cheese Sandwich (Ciabatta)520Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Solo
Italian Supreme Sandwich (Ciabatta)720Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Solo
Spicy Sausage Sandwich (Ciabatta)760Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Solo
Stromboli Sandwich (Ciabatta)540Milk, Soy, Wheat$8.99-$11.99Solo

The Spicy Sausage Ciabatta is the heaviest at 760 calories. The Italian Chef Salad is the lightest at 150.

Desserts & Drinks

Streusel pies, monkey bread, a big cookie, and drinks, from 140 to 840 calories.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Cinnamon Streusel (Mini, 1/4)190Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Sharing
Apple Streusel (Mini, 1/4)170Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Sharing
Cherry Streusel (Mini, 1/4)190Milk, Soy, Wheat$9.99-$12.99Sharing
Cinnamon Monkey Bread (1/4 pan)140Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.99Sharing
Big Chocolate Chip Cookie (1/6)190Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.99-$7.99Sharing
2-Liter Soft Drink840None$3.99-$4.99Sharing
20 oz Beverage250None$2.49-$3.49Solo
Fountain Drink200None$2.99-$3.99Solo

A 2-liter bottle carries 840 calories for the whole bottle. Cinnamon Monkey Bread is the lightest dessert at 140 a quarter pan.

Buffet

Three buffet options at dine-in spots, from $11.99 to $18.99 a person.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Lunch Buffet750Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$11.99-$15.99Sharing
Dinner Buffet850Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$14.99-$18.99Sharing
Senior Buffet650Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$12.99-$14.99Sharing

Lunch runs $11.99 to $15.99. Dinner runs $14.99 to $18.99. Hours vary by location.

Portion Guide

A Large pizza has ten slices and feeds three or four people. A Medium has eight slices and feeds two or three. A Jumbo has twelve slices and feeds four or five. A Mini has four slices and feeds one. A calzone feeds one person. A half order of wings is eight ounces and works as a side for two. The Ultimate Party Pizza has 52 slices and feeds up to 15 people with a day of notice.

Budget Picks

The Lunch Buffet at $11.99 is the cheapest all-you-can-eat meal for one person. A Pepperoni Calzone at $9.99 plus a Marinara cup at $0.75 runs $10.74 for one. A Large Cheese at $15.99 to $18.99 plus Breadsticks at $5.99 to $7.99 runs $21.98 to $26.98 and feeds three or four. A Large Classic Combo at $25.99 to $29.99 plus Breadsticks and a 2-liter runs $35.97 to $42.97 for the table. Two dipper cups at $0.75 each are the cheapest add-on on the menu.

Allergy Guide

Wheat is in every crust except the gluten-free crust. The gluten-free crust is baked with CSA-approved procedures, but the kitchen is not gluten free. Milk is in the cheese and in most sauces. Egg shows up in the Buffalo Chicken, the Chicken Bacon Ranch, the breakfast items, and the big cookie. Soy is in the crust dough and in many builds. Anchovies are a topping option and carry Fish. Ask the store about shared prep areas before ordering for a severe allergy.

You Might Also Like

If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.

FAQs

How much is a Large pizza at Godfather's?

A: A Large Cheese runs $15.99 to $18.99 at most US stores. A Large Specialty pizza runs $25.99 to $29.99. Prices vary by store and size.

Does Godfather's Pizza have a buffet?

A: Yes, at many dine-in spots. Lunch and dinner buffets run on different days by location. The buffet holds pizza, Broaster chicken, a salad bar, sides, and dessert pizza.

What is Taco Pie?

A: Taco Pie is built on taco sauce, beef, onions, cheddar, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, and extra cheddar on a thick crust. The Super Taco adds black olives and sour cream. One Large slice carries 330 calories.

What crusts does Godfather's have?

A: Four crusts: Original thick and chewy, Golden buttery pan-style, Thin light and crispy, and Mozza-Loaded stuffed with mozzarella for $2.75 more. A gluten-free crust is also available at most stores.

Does Godfather's have gluten-free pizza?

A: Yes, Cheese, 1-topping, and Specialty pizzas come on a gluten-free crust. The crust is baked using CSA-approved procedures or pre-packaged to take home. It is not available at the Grover or W. Center locations, and nothing is prepared in a gluten-free kitchen.

What is the Ultimate Party Pizza?

A: A 52-slice pizza for big groups. It needs a 24-hour advance order and is dine-in and carryout only. You can order it as cheese, 1-topping, or specialty with up to 4 toppings.

Bottom Line

Godfather's is the place for a thick-crust pie with the works, and the buffet is the move when the whole table wants a little of everything. Order the Taco Pie once, then pick your own favorite from the specialty list.

Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.

Similar Posts