|

Cold Stone Creamery Menu: Creations and Shakes

cold stone creamery menu

The granite slab is the whole show at Cold Stone Creamery. Your ice cream lands on a slab kept at 16 degrees below zero, and the crew folds your mix-ins into it right in front of you. Every cup is mixed to order, never scooped from a tub.

Sizes run Like It, Love It, and Gotta Have It, and the calories climb fast between them. This guide lists every Signature Creation, every base flavor, the cakes, the shakes, and the smoothies, with prices in typical US bands.

10 Best Value Items

Ten picks covering the lightest creations, the cheapest cups and the best shakes on the menu.

#ItemWhy Try ItPrice
1Create Your Own, Like It (Cake Batter)The cheapest full-size cup on the menu, 360 calories with one free mix-in.$5.50
2Very Berry Non-Dairy (Like It)The lightest Signature Creation at 330 calories, and dairy-free.$6.75
3Berry Berry Berry Good (Like It)Three berries in sweet cream, 390 calories in a Like It.$6.75
4Pineapple Blueberry Smoothie (12 oz)The lightest drink on the menu at 250 calories.$6.70
5Chocolate Silk Shake (12 oz)The lightest shake at 530 calories, served without whipped topping.$6.70
6Beary Beary Blue (Kids)The cheapest creation on the menu, 250 calories in a kids cup.$4.49
7Founder's Favorite (Like It)The original house favorite, 640 calories with pecans, brownie, fudge, and caramel.$6.75
8OREO Overload (Like It)Double OREO cookies in sweet cream, 530 calories in a Like It.$6.75
9Cake Batter Batter Batter (Like It)The richest pick in the top ten at 700 calories.$6.75
10S'more Moose Tracks, Please! (Like It)The seasonal holiday build, 640 calories with marshmallow and Moose Tracks fudge.$6.75

Pick from these ten first, then browse the full menu below.

Signature Creations

Twenty-four house builds in three sizes, with the very berry non-dairy as the lightest at 330.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Apple Pie A La Cold Stone460-990Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Banana Caramel Crunch450-1010Milk, Tree Nut$6.75-$9.99Solo
Berry Berry Berry Good390-860Milk$6.75-$9.99Solo
Birthday Cake Remix670-1180Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Cake Batter Batter Batter700-1210Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Cheesecake Fantasy420-920Egg, Milk, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Solo
Chocolate Devotion610-1150Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Coffee Lovers Only480-1060Milk, Soy, Tree Nut$6.75-$9.99Solo
Cookie Doughn't You Want Some610-1180Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Cookie Mintster480-1090Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Solo
Cookies Make Everything Batter510-1130Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Dough for It!630-1230Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Dough-lightful Peanut Butter620-1240Egg, Milk, Peanut, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Founder's Favorite640-1210Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nut, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip610-1150Milk, Soy$6.75-$9.99Solo
Mud Pie Mojo620-1210Milk, Peanut, Soy, Tree Nut, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
One Smart Brookie710-1230Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
OREO Overload530-1170Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Our Strawberry Blonde460-970Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Solo
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection590-1180Milk, Peanut, Soy$6.75-$9.99Sharing
REESE'S Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce540-1220Milk, Peanut, Soy$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Surrender to Strawberry420-920Egg, Milk, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Solo
Very Berry Non-Dairy330-730None$6.75-$9.99Solo
Don't Cry Over Spilled Silk510-960Peanut, Soy, Tree Nut$6.75-$9.99Solo

Dough-lightful Peanut Butter tops the table at 1,240 calories in a Gotta Have It. Very Berry Non-Dairy sits at the low end with 330 in a Like It. Most creations land between 500 and 700 calories in the small size.

Create Your Own Flavors

Sixteen base flavors in three sizes, with the mango as the lightest at 310 a cup.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Cake Batter360-860Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.50-$8.49Solo
Chocolate340-810Milk, Soy$5.50-$8.49Solo
Classic Cookie Dough370-890Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.50-$8.49Solo
Coffee340-810Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Mint340-810Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
French Vanilla340-820Egg, Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Strawberry330-800Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Banana320-770Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Peanut Butter380-910Milk, Peanut$5.50-$8.49Solo
Butter Pecan340-810Milk, Tree Nut$5.50-$8.49Solo
Cheesecake340-820Egg, Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Coconut340-800Milk, Tree Nut$5.50-$8.49Solo
Cotton Candy330-800Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Mango310-750Milk$5.50-$8.49Solo
Chocolate Peanut Butter440-1050Milk, Peanut, Soy$5.50-$8.49Solo
OREO Creme460-1100Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.50-$8.49Solo

OREO Creme is the richest base at 1,100 calories in a Gotta Have It. Mango is the lightest at 310 in a Like It. Chocolate Peanut Butter is the only other base that tops 1,000 calories.

Seasonal Creations

Seven limited-time builds, with the treat or treat as the lightest at 460 a cup.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
S'more Moose Tracks, Please!640-1210Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Holiday Spice and Everything Nice560-1080Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Pumpkin Spice Up Your Latte480-1060Milk, Soy$6.75-$9.99Solo
Treat or Treat460-1010Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Crumb and Get It610-1150Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
Going Bananas for JELL-O Pudding540-1120Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing
The Cat in the Hat's Cotton Candy Catastrophe500-1100Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.75-$9.99Sharing

S'more Moose Tracks tops the seasonal table at 1,210 calories in a Gotta Have It. Treat or Treat starts the table at 460 in a Like It. Holiday Spice and Pumpkin Spice Up Your Latte carry the winter flavors.

Creations for Kids

Three small creations for kids, with the sprinkleberry as the lightest at 240 a cup.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Beary Beary Blue250Milk$4.49-$5.49Kids
Delicious Dirt260Milk, Soy, Wheat$4.49-$5.49Kids
Sprinkleberry240Milk$4.49-$5.49Kids

Delicious Dirt is the biggest kids cup at 260 calories. Sprinkleberry is the smallest at 240. All three come in the kids size only.

Shakes

Seven blended shakes in two sizes, with the chocolate silk as the lightest at 530.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Cake Batter 'n Shake (12-20 oz)900-1440Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.70-$8.99Solo
Milk and OREO Cookies Shake (12-20 oz)890-1420Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.70-$8.99Solo
Oh Fudge! Shake (12-20 oz)870-1380Milk, Soy$6.70-$8.99Solo
REESE'S Chocolate Peanut Butter Dream Shake (12-20 oz)1160-1780Milk, Peanut, Soy$6.70-$8.99Sharing
Savory Strawberry Shake (12-20 oz)780-1200Milk$6.70-$8.99Solo
Very Vanilla Shake (12-20 oz)880-1310Milk$6.70-$8.99Solo
Chocolate Silk Shake (12-20 oz)530-890Soy, Tree Nut$6.70-$8.99Solo

The REESE'S Dream is the heaviest shake at 1,780 calories in a 20 oz. Chocolate Silk is the lightest at 530 in a 12 oz. Six shakes come with whipped topping. Chocolate Silk is served without it.

Smoothies

Five fruit smoothies in two sizes, with the pineapple blueberry as the lightest at 250.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Blueberry Banana Smoothie (12-20 oz)280-480None$6.70-$8.99Solo
Mango Pineapple Smoothie (12-20 oz)330-570None$6.70-$8.99Solo
Strawberry Mango Smoothie (12-20 oz)360-550None$6.70-$8.99Solo
Pineapple Blueberry Smoothie (12-20 oz)250-440None$6.70-$8.99Solo
Strawberry Banana Smoothie (12-20 oz)280-490None$6.70-$8.99Solo

Mango Pineapple is the heaviest smoothie at 570 calories in a 20 oz. Pineapple Blueberry is the lightest at 250 in a 12 oz. All five are made without dairy.

Ice Cream Cakes Pre-Order

Twelve cake flavors by the slice, with the strawberry passion as the lightest at 320.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
A Cheesecake Named Desire340-610Egg, Milk, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Cake Batter Confetti350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Chocolate Chipper350-630Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Coffeehouse Crunch410-630Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Cookies and Creamery330-570Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Midnight Delight370-590Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Mmmmmmint Chip330-570Milk, Soy$32.00-$48.99Group
OREO Cookies and Cream Extreme390-450Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Peanut Butter Playground400-560Egg, Milk, Peanut, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Strawberry Passion320-550Egg, Milk, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Tall, Dark and Delicious390-410Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Iced and Spiced380-620Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$37.00-$50.99Group

Chocolate Chipper and Coffeehouse Crunch tie at 630 calories a serving. Strawberry Passion is the lightest cake at 320 a serving. Iced and Spiced is the holiday cake on the list.

Cakes and Novelties Ready Now

Eight cake flavors ready today, with the strawberry passion as the lightest at 370 a serving.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
A Cheesecake Named Desire390-410Egg, Milk, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Cake Batter Confetti420-450Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Midnight Delight430-480Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Mmmmmmint Chip390-410Milk, Soy$32.00-$48.99Group
Peanut Butter Playground390-410Egg, Milk, Peanut, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Cookies and Creamery390-420Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
OREO Cookies and Cream Extreme390-450Milk, Soy, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group
Strawberry Passion370-390Egg, Milk, Wheat$32.00-$48.99Group

Midnight Delight is the richest ready-now cake at 480 calories a serving. Strawberry Passion is the lightest at 390. These cakes sit in the freezer case for same-day pickup.

Themed Cakes

Five licensed party cakes in two sizes, with the licensed party cakes running 350 to 600.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Spiderman Themed Cake350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$47.00-$114.99Group
MarioKart Themed Cake350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$47.00-$114.99Group
Princess Themed Cake350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$47.00-$114.99Group
Bluey Themed Cake350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$47.00-$114.99Group
Mermaid Themed Cake350-600Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$47.00-$114.99Group

All five themed cakes come in the same two sizes. Order ahead, since themed cakes are made to order.

Freezer and Novelties

Quarts, cups, sandwiches and cupcakes to take home, with the founders favorite and OREO overload tied at 280.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Cake Batter Batter Batter Pre-packed Quart290Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$10.00-$12.49Group
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection Pre-packed Quart300Milk, Peanut, Soy$10.00-$12.49Group
Founder's Favorite Pre-packed Quart280Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nut, Wheat$10.00-$12.49Group
OREO Overload Pre-packed Quart280Milk, Soy, Wheat$10.00-$12.49Group
REESE'S Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack330Milk, Peanut, Soy$20.00-$22.99Group
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack480-540Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$16.00-$18.49Group
Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack320Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$20.00-$22.99Group

The Peanut Butter Cup Perfection quart is the richest quart at 300 calories a serving. The Founder's Favorite and OREO Overload quarts tie at 280. The cookie sandwich 4-pack is the biggest single item here at 540 calories.

Mix-Ins and Waffle Cones

Ten mix-ins and a fresh waffle cone, with the strawberries as the lightest at 30 a serving.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
OREO Cookies Mix-In110Soy, Wheat$1.19-$1.99Extra
Cookie Dough Mix-In130Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$1.19-$1.99Extra
Brownie Mix-In140Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$1.19-$1.99Extra
Hot Fudge Mix-In120Milk, Soy$1.19-$1.99Extra
Caramel Mix-In90Milk, Soy$1.19-$1.99Extra
Pecans Mix-In100Tree Nut$1.19-$1.99Extra
Roasted Almonds Mix-In90Tree Nut$1.19-$1.99Extra
Strawberries Mix-In30None$1.19-$1.99Extra
Banana Mix-In50None$1.19-$1.99Extra
Waffle Cone140Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$1.99-$2.99Extra

The brownie and the waffle cone tie as the heaviest at 140 calories a serving. Strawberries are the lightest at 30. A waffle cone adds 140 calories to any cup.

Portion Guide

Like It is the small cup, and it already holds plenty for one person. Love It suits a big appetite, and Gotta Have It is built for sharing. A 12 oz shake drinks like a meal. One slice of cake feeds one guest, and a 6 inch round serves eight.

Budget Picks

A kids creation runs $4.49 to $5.49. A Like It creation plus a 12 oz smoothie runs $13.45 to $16.98. Two Like It creations run $13.50 to $15.98. A 6 inch round cake at $32.00 to $36.99 serves eight, which works out to about $4.00 to $4.62 a slice.

Allergy Guide

Milk shows up in nearly every cup, since the bases are dairy ice cream. The two non-dairy creations skip milk entirely. Peanuts and tree nuts turn up in the peanut butter builds and the pecan and almond mix-ins. Wheat hides in the brownies, cookie dough, and waffle cones. Tell the crew about a severe allergy before they start folding, because every order shares the same cold stone.

You Might Also Like

If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.

FAQs

How much is a Like It at Cold Stone?

A: A Like It creation runs $6.75 to $7.99 at most US stores. A Create Your Own Like It runs $5.50 to $6.49. The Like It is the smallest size on the menu.

What is the lowest calorie creation at Cold Stone?

A: Very Berry Non-Dairy in a Like It is the lightest Signature Creation at 330 calories. The smoothies start at 250 calories in a 12 oz cup.

Does Cold Stone have dairy-free ice cream?

A: Yes, two Signature Creations are dairy-free: Very Berry Non-Dairy and Don't Cry Over Spilled Silk. Sorbet bases are also available for Create Your Own cups.

Can I order a Cold Stone cake the same day?

A: Ready Now cakes sit in the freezer case for same-day pickup. Pre-order cakes are made to order, so order ahead for a specific date.

What sizes do Cold Stone creations come in?

A: Like It is a 5 oz scoop, Love It is 8 oz, and Gotta Have It is 12 oz. Kids cups are smaller, and pints and quarts are sold to take home.

Does Cold Stone sell ice cream to take home?

A: Yes, pre-packed quarts sit in the freezer case for $10.00 to $12.49. The case also holds 6-packs of ice cream cups and cupcakes, and 4-packs of cookie sandwiches.

Bottom Line

Cold Stone earns its price with the show on the slab and the freedom to build your own cup. The Like It size is enough for most people, and the fruit creations keep the calories in check. Order the cake a day ahead, and save the Gotta Have It for sharing.

Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.

Similar Posts