Menu | Ice Cream & Desserts

Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu: Concretes, Sundaes and Shakes

andys frozen custard menu

Frozen custard is not ice cream. Egg yolk and less air make it denser and richer, and Andy's churns it fresh in the store all day, in vanilla or chocolate, then builds every treat from those two bases.

Prices, calories and allergens for every section follow below, from the concretes to the take-home packs. Concretes run up to 1,120 calories in a Jackhammer, and iced tea runs just 10 calories, so the range is easy to see before you order.

10 Best Value Items

Ten picks from a $1.94 custard cup to the signature BootDaddy concrete, led by the Jackhammer and the banana split.

#ItemWhy Try ItPrice
1BootDaddy ConcreteThe signature concrete, Oreo, caramel and hot fudge, 930 calories.$5.19-$8.04
2Triple Chocolate ConcreteChocolate custard with cookie dough and melted chocolate chip, 980 calories.$4.64-$7.81
3Ozark Turtle SundaeHot fudge, caramel and pecans over vanilla custard, 980 calories.$5.34-$8.27
4Banana SplitA whole banana with strawberries, marshmallow crème and nuts, 980 calories.$5.79-$9.19
5Vanilla Frozen Custard CupThe plainest cup, vanilla custard on its own, 300 calories.$1.94-$4.47
6ShakesCustard blended thick with your pick of topping, 710 calories.$3.89-$6.66
7Stolen Brownie SundaeBrownie, hot fudge and pecans with a cherry on top, 1,080 calories.$5.34-$8.50
8Butter Pecan ConcreteButterscotch and roasted pecans in vanilla custard, 890 calories.$4.84-$7.81
9Root Beer FloatSprecher root beer over vanilla custard, 520 calories.$3.49-$6.08
10Zarlengo's Italian IceA dairy-free frozen treat at 250 calories.$2.39-$5.16

A BootDaddy Concrete with a Root Beer Float runs $8.68 to $14.12 for one person.

Concretes & Jackhammers

Eighteen concretes in small, medium and large, from the BootDaddy to the Jackhammer, with a build-your-own option too.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
BootDaddy Concrete930Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$5.19-$8.04Solo
Triple Chocolate Concrete980Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$4.64-$7.81Solo
Ooey Gooey Concrete960Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$4.84-$8.04Solo
Snowmonster Concrete910Egg, Milk, Soy$4.64-$7.92Solo
Butter Pecan Concrete890Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$4.84-$7.81Solo
Mint Chip Concrete860Egg, Milk, Soy$4.64-$7.69Solo
Jitterbug Concrete940Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$6.89-$7.92Solo
Strawberry & Oreo Concrete900Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.79-$7.81Solo
Choc-O-Rocko Concrete970Egg, Milk, Tree Nuts$6.99-$8.04Solo
Cherry Bash Concrete880Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$6.69-$7.69Solo
Almond Delight Concrete920Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$4.84-$7.64Solo
German Chocolate Concrete950Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$4.84-$7.64Solo
Pretzel Caramel Crunch Concrete900Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.69-$7.69Solo
The Jackhammer1120Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$4.79-$8.50Solo
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer1090Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Wheat$5.54-$8.38Solo
Rico Suave Jackhammer1020Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$5.79-$8.27Solo
Build Your Own Concrete769Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$3.89-$6.54Solo
Build Your Own Jackhammer1120Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$5.69-$8.50Solo

The lightest is the Build Your Own Concrete at 769 calories. The heaviest are The Jackhammer and the Build Your Own Jackhammer, tied at 1,120 calories. The BootDaddy Concrete runs 930 calories.

Sundaes & Splits

Nine sundaes and splits in regular and large, from the Ozark Turtle to the banana split.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Ozark Turtle Sundae980Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$5.34-$8.27Solo
The Original Straw-Ana Sundae860Egg, Milk$4.39-$8.04Solo
Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans1010Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$4.59-$8.38Solo
Stolen Brownie Sundae1080Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$5.34-$8.50Solo
Tin Roof Sundae960Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy$7.19-$8.27Solo
Build Your Own Sundae425Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$3.64-$5.45Solo
Kids' Sundae293Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$2.89-$3.32Kids
Banana Split980Egg, Milk, Tree Nuts$5.79-$9.19Sharing
Turtle Split1080Egg, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts$5.79-$9.53Sharing

The lightest is the Kids' Sundae at 293 calories. The heaviest are the Stolen Brownie Sundae and the Turtle Split, tied at 1,080 calories. The Ozark Turtle Sundae runs 980 calories.

Seasonal Treats

Four fall treats while they last, with apple pie and pumpkin pie concretes and a s'mores Jackhammer.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Apple Pie Concrete1050Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.79-$7.81Solo
Pumpkin Pie Concrete1020Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.79-$7.81Solo
S'mores Jackhammer1000Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$7.19-$8.27Solo
Apple Pie Sundae950Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.99-$8.04Solo

The lightest is the Apple Pie Sundae at 950 calories. The heaviest is the Apple Pie Concrete at 1,050 calories. The Pumpkin Pie Concrete runs 1,020 calories.

Cups & Cones

Eight plain and custom cups, cones and bars, from a $1.94 small cup to the Italian ice.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Vanilla Frozen Custard Cup300Egg, Milk$1.94-$4.47Solo
Chocolate Frozen Custard Cup318Egg, Milk$1.94-$4.47Solo
Custom Cup480Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$5.29-$6.08Solo
Custom Cone480Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$5.29-$6.08Solo
Waffle Cake Cone430Egg, Milk, Wheat$3.99-$4.59Solo
Zarlengo's Italian Ice250None$2.39-$5.16Solo
Frozen Custard Bar250Egg, Milk$2.99-$3.44Solo
Frozen Custard Bar 4-Pack1000Egg, Milk$9.99-$11.49Family

The lightest are the Zarlengo's Italian Ice and the Frozen Custard Bar, tied at 250 calories. The heaviest is the Frozen Custard Bar 4-Pack at 1,000 calories. The Custom Cup runs 480 calories.

Shakes, Malts & Freezes

Seven thick drinks in small and large, from plain shakes to the Double Double Malt at the top.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Shakes710Egg, Milk$3.89-$6.66Solo
Malts760Egg, Milk$3.89-$6.89Solo
Old-Fashioned Freezes620Egg, Milk$3.89-$6.31Solo
Birthday Shake890Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.29-$7.23Solo
Choco Express Shake940Egg, Milk, Soy$6.49-$7.46Solo
Strawberry Oreo Cookie Shake960Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat$6.49-$7.46Solo
Double Double Malt1020Egg, Milk, Wheat$6.79-$7.81Solo

The lightest is the Old-Fashioned Freeze at 620 calories. The heaviest is the Double Double Malt at 1,020 calories. The Shakes run 710 calories.

Soda Shoppe

Thirteen soda-fountain drinks from floats and freezes to old-fashioned sodas and yummy sodas with custard.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Root Beer Float520Egg, Milk$3.49-$6.08Solo
Coke Float500Egg, Milk$3.49-$6.08Solo
Cream Soda Float540Egg, Milk$3.49-$6.08Solo
Root Beer Freeze610Egg, Milk$3.89-$6.31Solo
Cream Soda Freeze620Egg, Milk$3.89-$6.31Solo
Strawberry Old-Fashioned Soda310Egg, Milk$3.49-$5.51Solo
Raspberry Old-Fashioned Soda300Egg, Milk$3.49-$5.51Solo
Key Lime Old-Fashioned Soda290Egg, Milk$3.49-$5.51Solo
Chocolate Old-Fashioned Soda390Egg, Milk, Soy$3.49-$5.74Solo
Butterscotch Brew Yummy Soda340Egg, Milk, Soy$4.99-$5.74Solo
Cherry Coke Yummy Soda330Egg, Milk$4.99-$5.74Solo
Dr Pepper Yummy Soda540Egg, Milk$5.29-$6.08Solo
Cherry Limeade Yummy Soda310Egg, Milk$4.99-$5.74Solo

The lightest is the Key Lime Old-Fashioned Soda at 290 calories. The heaviest is the Cream Soda Freeze at 620 calories. The Root Beer Float runs 520 calories.

Iced Lattes & Refreshers

Ten lattes and light drinks from espresso lattes to iced tea, soft drinks and bottled water.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Vanilla Fudge Yummy Latte410Egg, Milk, Soy$5.29-$6.08Solo
Vanilla Caramel Yummy Latte390Egg, Milk, Soy$5.29-$6.08Solo
Chocolate Fudge Yummy Latte440Egg, Milk, Soy$5.49-$6.31Solo
Chocolate Caramel Yummy Latte420Egg, Milk, Soy$5.49-$6.31Solo
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea10None$1.69-$3.21Solo
Soft Drinks140None$1.29-$2.86Solo
Sprecher Soda210None$1.54-$4.01Solo
Bottled Sprecher Cream Soda180None$2.99-$3.44Solo
Bottled Sprecher Root Beer190None$2.99-$3.44Solo
Bottled Water0None$1.69-$1.94Solo

The lightest is the Bottled Water at 0 calories. The heaviest is the Chocolate Fudge Yummy Latte at 440 calories. The Vanilla Fudge Yummy Latte runs 410 calories.

Andy's Anywhere

Six take-home packs from a pint to a half gallon, with a Pick 6 and a Quart Combo for sharing.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Pick 6 (6 Half-Pints)2400-3690Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$15.99-$18.39Family
Vanilla or Chocolate Pint800Egg, Milk$3.69-$6.89Family
Vanilla or Chocolate Quart1600Egg, Milk$5.69-$12.64Family
Vanilla or Chocolate Half Gallon3200Egg, Milk$9.69-$11.14Family
Specialty Pint Flavors760Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$4.44-$8.04Family
Quart Combo2040Egg, Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat$11.79-$14.94Family

The lightest is the Specialty Pint at 760 calories. The heaviest is the Pick 6 at 2,400 to 3,690 calories for the set. The Quart Combo runs 2,040 calories.

Caramel Apples

Three caramel apples, plain, Reese's Pieces or pecan, made for fall and easy to share.

ItemCaloriesAllergensPrice RangeBest For
Classic Caramel Apple420Milk$5.99-$6.89Sharing
Reese's Pieces Caramel Apple560Milk, Peanuts, Soy$6.49-$7.46Sharing
Pecan Caramel Apple510Milk, Tree Nuts$6.29-$7.23Sharing

The lightest is the Classic Caramel Apple at 420 calories. The heaviest is the Reese's Pieces Caramel Apple at 560 calories. The Pecan Caramel Apple runs 510 calories.

Portion Guide

Concretes come in Small, Medium and Large, and sundaes come in Regular and Large. Shakes and malts come in Small and Large, and plain custard cups come in Small, Medium, Large and Jumbo. One concrete or sundae is one person's treat. A Pick 6 feeds six people, and a Quart Combo feeds four to six.

Budget Picks

Cheapest drink: a soft drink at $1.29 at the low end. Cheapest treat: a small plain custard cup at $1.94 at the low end. Best solo value: a Build Your Own Concrete (Small) at $3.89 at the low end. Best family deal: a Quart Combo at $11.79 at the low end, about $2.95 a person for four.

Allergy Guide

Milk shows up in 71 rows and Egg in 68, since frozen custard is made with milk and egg yolk. Soy shows up in 43 rows, Wheat in 26, Tree Nuts in 24 and Peanuts in 13. The plainest picks are the Zarlengo's Italian Ice, iced tea, soft drinks and bottled water, which list no allergens. Toppings are added to order, so ask in store about any topping before you order.

You Might Also Like

If you want to see the full and updated menu list of any other restaurant here, click on any box.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many calories are in an Andy's BootDaddy Concrete?

930 calories in a regular cup. A small runs about 800, and a large runs about 1,400, per the chain's own menu PDF and the nutrition calculator.

Does Andy's Frozen Custard have dairy-free options?

No custard item is dairy-free, since frozen custard is made with milk and egg yolk. The dairy-free picks are Zarlengo's Italian Ice, iced tea, soft drinks and bottled water.

How many Andy's Frozen Custard locations are there?

190 locations in 15 states, per the chain's own October 2026 release. Wikipedia lists 192.

What is a Jackhammer at Andy's?

A concrete filled through the center with a drizzly topping of your choice. The named ones are the James Brownie Funky, with peanut butter and brownies, and the Rico Suave, with pecans and Oreos.

Does Andy's Frozen Custard have gift cards?

Yes, gift cards are sold in stores and make a useful gift for frozen custard fans. Amounts and designs vary by location.

What time does Andy's Frozen Custard open and close?

Most stores open at 11:00 AM. Summer hours run to 11:30 PM Sunday to Thursday and midnight Friday and Saturday, and winter hours close an hour earlier. Hours vary by location.

Bottom Line

The BootDaddy is the concrete to try first, and the Ozark Turtle is the sundae that shows the custard at its best. A plain cup keeps the bill low, and a quart pack is the better buy when the whole table wants dessert.

Note: Prices are typical US rates and may vary by location.

Similar Posts